Week 13 Discussion Topic: Cookie Notice for At-Risk Users

The goal for today is to create a security-planner like cookie label for more than one at-risk group.

(This should help you think about and plan for your final project.)

Security Planner

Start by looking at Consumer Report’s Security Planner tool. It is an interactive tool designed to help a person with their cybersecurity by creating a personalized plan based on their specific needs and risk factors. The idea is that a person answers a few questions about their technology use, their specific concerns, and situational factors, and then gets a customized, prioritized list of security recommendations vetted by experts that will help them protect themselves. This is particularly useful for people at higher-than-typical risk of cyberattacks. (Full disclosure: I was one of the experts consulted in an early version of this planner by Citizen Lab.)

At-Risk Users

The reading for this week has a list of at-risk user groups that have been studied by usable security and privacy researchers. Table I has a great list, though the whole paper discussed many ways to think of at-risk users.

Remember, users can be at-risk for one of two reasons:

  1. They have a higher risk because they are being specifically targetted or attacked by someone or some group
  2. They have a higher risk because the potential harms resulting from attacks are higher

Pick three different types of at-risk users that might be particularly at-risk from web browser cookies and the tracking that those cookies enable. Try to pick groups that are different from each other in important ways, and/or have different types of concerns about cookies and web tracking.

Concerns

For each of these three groups, try to write down the particular concerns that each group would have about cookies and web tracking. What, specifically is that group worried about and why should they be more concerned than other people about cookies (in general) or specific types / uses of cookies in particular or cookie use on specific webpages?

Information

If you are going to design a cookie nutrition label, that label will need to provide specific information to users that they will find useful.

Make a list of what information each user group would find useful / important.

Recommendations

What would you (as a security/privacy expert) recommend for each of these groups?

Try to design a “security planner” type interface. It should have 2 screens:

  1. A screen with a question and a small number of options (e.g. “What are your main security / privacy concerns?”)
  2. A screen that displays a set of information and/or recommendations, based on the answers to that first question.