Week 11 Discussion Topic: Nudges and Cookies

Heuristic and Biases

Incomplete Information

When people don’t have relevant information, they make tend to make decisions that favor the information they do have

Asymmetric Information

When one person has more information than another, they can use that information to take advantage of the lesser-information person

Anchoring

When we face a new situation, we tend to take the first thing we see as an anchor, and then evaluate each subsequent thing by comparing it to the anchor

Loss Aversion

We tend to value avoiding a loss is more than an equivalent gain

Framing Effects

We tend to make decisions based on the way that options are framed when they are presented to us

Hyperbolic Discounting

We tend to value having things right now much more than we value having that same thing in the future

Optimism Bias

We tend to be biased toward making optimistic choices

Post-completion Errors

We often make errors when we complete a primary task, but still have secondary tasks to complete

Status Quo Bias

We tend to (strong) prefer to keep things they same as they are now rather than changing them

Types of Nudges

A nudge is ‘any aspect of the choice architecture that alters people’s behavior in a predictable way without forbidding any options or significantly changing their economic incentives.”

Controlling Information

We can nudge people toward a decision by giving them specific information relevant to that decision. We do that both by providing general education (ahead-of-time) and by providing real-time feedback.

Presentation and Framing

We can nudge people toward a decision by changing the way a decision and the possible options are presented. We do that by taking advantage of framing effects (positive/negative framing, gain/loss framing), ordering effects (we tend to prefer the first/top/left option), the availability heuristic (we think risks are more likely if examples easily come to mind), and by structuring options.

Defaults

We can nudge people toward a decision by changing the default option to the one we want people to choose. This takes advantage of status quo bias. We often do this by thinking carefully about whether options are opt-in or opt-out.

Incentives

We can nudge people toward a decision by providing incentives for the option we want them to choose. Incentives can include providng rewards or lowering costs for our preferred options, and/or punishments or more difficult features for less preferred options.

Reversability and errors

We can nudge people toward making risky decisions by making those decisions reverable, or otherwise making it easy to recover from errors. We do that by providing a cooling-off period, automated completion, or an undo option.

Timing

We can nudge people toward or away from specific decisions by changing the timing of their decision. We do that by controlling when information or other nudges are displayed to users, or by noticing when users are in a “hot” state and encouraging/requiring them to shift their decision to a different time.