Week 5 Discussion Topic: Choosing Passwords
Goal for today: Do people choose passwords for security?
Data
I have data collected in 2015 from 134 people that includes every website they visited on their computer (include all websites where they entered a password), along with information about the passwords that they entered and information about the websites they visited. Almost all of them were students.
Hypotheses
1. Reuse Focused Password Choice
Users primarily choose a single, complex password that meets most security requirements, and reuse that password across as many websites as will allow it
2. Creation-Focused Password Choice
Users primarily choose password by focusing on the ease of creating a password (e.g. the simplest allowable password)
3. Usage-Focused Password Choice
Users primarily choose passwords by making a security / usability tradeoff and focusing on the usability needs, such as how frequently they enter the password or how frequently they visit the website.
4. Security-Focused Password Choice
Users primarily choose passwords my making a security / usability tradeoff and focusing on the security needs of the website.
Charts / Info
Here are a bunch of charts / data that might be helpful in answering these questions:
- Average Password Complexity, by category of website. Table 3
- Percentage of websites with the most reused password. Figure 2
- Password complexity and how people perceive the passwords. Figure 1
- Password length. Figure 4
- Password character classes. Figure 5
- Password overall complexity. Figure 3
- Passwords and website importance. Table 4
- Passwords and website visits. Table 2
- Passwords and website importance. Table 5
And some interesting findings / data points that might be helpful.
-
“Out of the 134 users in this study, only 2 have exactly 1 password that they reuse everywhere (1.5% of users). These two users reused their single password on 10 and 18 different websites during the 6 weeks of the study.”
-
“The remaining 132 users all had more than one password that they had used, with different websites having different passwords. Most users had four to eight passwords”
-
“approximately half of our users (40%, 54 out of 134) using their most dominant password on fewer than 50% of the websites they have passwords on, and only 19 users (14%) using their most dominant password on 75% or more of websites.”
-
“On average, the passwords entered into websites have 21 bits of complexity more than the password composition policy requires. This is a substantial difference; it roughly corresponds to the difference between a 7 character password (36 bits of complexity) and an 11 character password (57 bits of complexity), where the passwords are composed of lowercase letters and numbers.”
-
“Only 16.2% of passwords are at or below the minimum requirements for the website they are used in. A total of 42% of users (56 out of 134) don’t have a single password that is. at or below the minimum required complexity; all of their passwords are more complex than the website where they were used requires them to be.”
-
“For each participant, we calculated the combined complexity requirements of all of the websites where they used each of their passwords, and compared that to the complexity of the password that was chosen. Only 30% of reused passwords are at or below this combined minimum. This means that about 70% of passwords are more complex than required on all of the websites that they are used on.”
-
“Entering passwords can be a very time-consuming task; recent estimates suggest that it takes 10–14 seconds to enter a password every time it is needed [27], and users enter a password approximately 3.2 times per day [2], which, when combined, suggest that users are spending over 3 hours per year just entering passwords”
-
“We calculated the number of times a password was entered into each website and divided it by the number of days between the first and last uses of the website by that user. This gives us an estimate for how often a password needs to be entered—the number of password entries per day. This has very little correlation with the complexity of the password used (r=0.00, P = 0.72, 95% CI: [-0.04, 0.03]).”
-
“Looking at how many webpages on the site the user is able to view before being asked to log in again. If, like one of our participants, you are able to view 10,000 different pages on reddit in 6 weeks but are only asked to log in once, that may seem like a very efficient use of your time entering your password. We calculated the number of visits per password entry, but also found very little correlation with the complexity of the password used (r(2531)=0.03, P = 0.15, 95% CI: [-0.01, 0.06]).”
-
“We also find a very small correlation here (r(2531)=-0.03, P = 0.16, 95% CI: [-0.06, 0.01]) between the number of webpage visits per day on a website and the complexity of the password used on that website.”
-
“We found a positive correlation between these importance ratings and the complexity of passwords used on that website (r(1517)=0.09, P < 0.001, 95% CI: [0.04, 0.14]).”
All Together
All of the above data can be found in a single file here: Password Evidence
Original Paper
Prioritizing security over usability: Strategies for how people choose passwords, by Rick Wash and Emilee Rader. Journal of Cybersecurity, June 2021.
Appendix: University Passwords
A critical situation: university passwords
Following the principle of strong inference, we specifically looked for situations that can help us distinguish between competing hypotheses. In the section on “Hypotheses on password choices”, we described such a situation: an organization’s single sign on. A single sign on password both needs to be entered frequently (high usability requirements) and also protects a large amount of important information (high security requirements). In such a situation, Hypotheses 3 and 4 make different predictions. If users are primarily following a strategy emphasizing usability (H3), they most should choose a low-complexity password, i.e. easy to enter. If they primarily are following a strategy emphasizing security (H4), then they should choose a high-complexity password.
All users in our study were associated with a single university, and as such, all of them had a password with that university. The complexity of these passwords is labeled “university” in Table 3. These passwords were, on average, the highest complexity passwords of any category of website. Following the logic of “strong inference,” this data suggest that strategies following H4 are more likely to be followed by users than strategies from H3.
We can also use this situation to compare Hypothesis 4 and Hypothesis 2 by looking at the password policy. At the time of the study, the minimum complexity for passwords at that university was 47 bits. This is relatively complex password policy, but it is still over 10 bits lower than the actual passwords. That is, the actual university passwords were on average 10 bits of entropy more complex than they were required to be, suggesting that users were not necessarily following Hypothesis 2 either.
University passwords are only a single website, but they represent a “critical experiment” that allows us to conduct strong inference because our three hypotheses make different predictions in this situation [11]. H2 and H3 both predict low complexity passwords, and H4 predicts high complexity passwords. The data are most consistent with Hypothesis 4, that users are following a strategy of choosing more complex passwords on websites with higher security needs.