Week 8 Discussion Topic: Encrypted Email
Goal for today: Make a good plan for the secure email assignment, which is due two weeks from today.
Try Out Encrypted Email
To get a better handle on encrypted communication, let’s try out encrypted email. Find a partner in class. I’d like you to try to install and use a program to send an encrypted email to that person, and also receive an encrypted email from that person.
The best way I’ve seen to do this is Mailvelope. It is a free extension built for Google Chrome that integrates with both Gmail and Outlook.
Install Mailvelope
You will need to use Google Chrome for this exercise. Open Google Chrome, go to Mailvelope, and click on the “Download” button in the upper right. Go through the process of installing the Chrome extension. Once it is installed, you will need to click on the extension (looks like a puzzle piece in the upper right corner) to open it. Follow the instructions to create your own private key.
As you do this, pay attention to the user interface, and in particular the sequence of steps you have to do. This is a security ceremony. How many steps steps is this? How confusing is this? Are the opportunities to screw up? Take notes on all of the steps you had to go through.
Next, work with your partner to make sure you both have installed Mailvelope and have it working. Make sure you both upload your newly created key to the keyserver.
Send your partner encrypted email
For the next step, you should try to figure out how to send your partner an encrypted email. You will need to use either Gmail or Outlook. You can send whatever message you want, but it must be encrypted so that only your partner can read it. The other person should then open up the email and read it.
Try to figure out how to do that. You might need to enable the extension for the specific website.
As you do this, take notes on the steps you went through. Include both the successful steps and the failures.
Could you do this better?
Now that you’ve got your concrete lists written down, could you design this better? What would want to do differently than Mailvelope?
Secure Email
The next assignment is to create new email app that uses a similar kind of encryption. Instead of PGP, it uses a newer encryption technology called “Identity-based Encryption”.
Read through the assignment, and then Talk with your partner:
- What is different about key management for this system? How are they similar or different to mailvelope in a web browser?
- Do we have to go through all of the same steps you wrote down for Mailvelope? Can you make things simpler?
- Are there any additional steps you’ll need?
Make a list of interfaces to design
Work with your partner and make a list of which interfaces you’ll need to design for the assignment.