Final Proposal for PhD Students

This class has 4 assignments: 1 quick-and-dirty usabilty study, and then 3 different types of usable security studies: a user research study, designing a new interface, and designing a new communication (warning / nutrition label). The last of these three studies stands in and functions as the final project for the course.

For PhD students, I would like you do to a different final project. Instead of the 3rd usable security study, I would like you to produce a detailed research proposal to do a traditional-style usable privacy or security research study. You don’t have to do the study, but you should present a proposal that is detailed enough that you could submit it to IRB and do the study.

Conceptual Details

The proposal should be for a research project that could be published in a usable privacy and security venue. But, more specifically, it should specifically be a traditional usable privacy or security study: it should look at a specific technology, and evaluate whether that technology someone improves usability and/or privacy/security.

As you think about research projects, think about ways you can make a contribution by writing a paper that:

  • proposes a new way of doing things. That new way has better security / privacy properties (and hopefully, no worse on usability)
  • proposes a new way of doing things. That new way has better usability properties (and hopefully, no worse on security / privacy)
  • presents an examination of the effectiveness of a new (at the time) security or privacy technology as used in the real world

If you propose a new way of doing things – a new technology, a new feature for an existing technology, etc. – you should have enough designed that you can study it. That is, you should have enough design work completed to have a prototype that you can actually test empirically. You cannot propose to study a hypothetical interface that does not yet exist. You may need to spend some time designing a new interface and/or communication, and creating a prototype or mocked-up version of it.

You proposal should contain a detailed plan for research, using a research methods you are familiar with. I highly recommend modeling the proposed research after one or more of the research papers you read during the semester. Pay attention to the research methods – how the paper(s) study things – and then model your proposed project on one of those papers.

Proposal Details

The scope of the proposal should be to do a research project that will produce a single research paper. You must describe in detail the problem you want to study, the theories/ideas you want to use to study it, and the methods you plan to use. You should also include a budget of resources needed, including estimates for amounts of money and estimates of amounts of time (and from whom, if it needs other people).

The proposal should be written using ACM’s master template in manuscript form. The proposal should be less than about 8000 words, and can be substantially less.

Judy Olson’s Famous 10 Questions

When I write research proposals, I find it very helpful to use Judy Olson’s Famous 10 Questions to help guide my thinking. Judy Olson (a famous Human-Computer Interaction researcher) created a list of 10 questions that all research projects should be able to answer. Every research paper should have an answer to all of these questions, and every proposal should have an answer (or a guess at what the answer will be) for all of these questions. You should NOT organize your proposal around these questions, but you should make sure that your document includes an answer to all 10 questions.

  1. What is the problem? (in the theoretical debate, the world)
  2. Who cares? (an argument about its importance)
  3. What have others done? (the lit review, but pointed as an argument)
  4. What is your approach? (your general approach, the new idea)
  5. What are you going to do explicitly? (your operationalization, investigation)
  6. What will happen? (or did happen, if you have results)
  7. What does this mean? (in terms of answering the problem)
  8. Who cares? (in what way is this important)
  9. Where will you publish these results? (who is the audience?)
  10. What will you be doing in 5 years? (how does this lead to bigger and better things?)

Due

The final proposal is due on the first day of finals period: Friday Dec 12th AOE. PhD students should do this instead of the final (nutrition label) assignment.